Is selling on Etsy worth it? Pros, cons, and other options

I’ve sold vintage ’90s band tees on Etsy for a few years. I’ll show you why selling on Etsy is worth it and share some of the tips I’ve picked up along the way. 

My quick 30-second verdict

Etsy is worth it for selling handmade goods, vintage items, and craft supplies. However, the platform maintains strict listing rules. It prohibits most mass‑produced retail arbitrage and generic reselling, allowing only handmade items, qualifying vintage goods, and craft supplies. 

Why is selling on Etsy worth it?

What is Etsy?

With over 5 million sellers and 86 million active buyers, Etsy gives crafters, vintage sellers, and other creators access to buyers actively searching for unique, handcrafted products. Many buyers prefer the original, hand-crafted quality goods available on Etsy, and are willing to pay a premium. 

Here’s a look at some of the top-selling items on Etsy:

• Personalized jewelry: Etsy buyers want meaningful pieces like name necklaces, birthstone rings, and engraved pieces. Most personalized jewelry sells for between $20 and $200, depending on materials, finishes, and customization.

• Wall art: Digital prints, posters, canvas art, and printable wall decor sell year-round. Buyers love instant downloads and affordable home styling options, typically priced from $2 to $20, with premium canvas pieces higher.

• Custom clothing: Event shirts, hoodies, and personalized apparel stay top sellers thanks to strong niche demand. Pricing usually ranges from $15 to $300, depending on whether the item is handmade, embroidered, or print-on-demand.
  ‍
• Stickers: Planner stickers, laptop decals, and custom aesthetic designs move quickly because buyers frequently repurchase them. Sticker packs usually cost between $3 and $8, making them budget-friendly and high-volume sellers.

Etsy’s features

Etsy offers sellers branding controls, digital product support, mobile listing tools, and a global reach. Here are 6 reasons why selling on Etsy is worth it:

Reason #1: Branding and shop organization

Etsy lets you create a professional and unique storefront that stands out. Upload custom banners, logos, and product photography. You can make a simple-to-navigate storefront so buyers can find your products quickly.

A well-crafted and polished storefront reinforces your creative identity and increases the chances that your shop will be profitable. Etsy’s setup works particularly well if you want a store that reflects your brand and feels intentional rather than cluttered or generic.

Reason #2: Ability to sell digital products and renewals

You can sell digital goods like printables, templates, artwork, and downloadable files. These are highly scalable and can be very profitable when demand is consistent. Sellers who offer these goods eliminate shipping logistics, physical inventory, and handling costs, which improves margins.

Reason #3: Listing tools and inventory tracking

Etsy offers listing tools with templates and an intuitive interface for quick uploads. It also provides a mobile app, which simplifies adding photos, editing listings, and responding to messages from anywhere. The platform includes inventory-tracking features to monitor stock levels and manage products. 

Reason #4: Global reach and visibility

Etsy connects sellers with buyers in over 200 countries through built-in currency conversion, international tax handling, translated pages, and automated customs forms. This global infrastructure enables small sellers to expand their reach without managing complex cross-border logistics themselves.

The platform also drives external traffic through off-site ads on Google, Facebook, Instagram, and Pinterest. You can opt to purchase these ads if your shop makes under $10,000/year. However, if your annual revenue exceeds $10,000, Etsy requires you to pay 12% on orders generated from off-site ads.

Reason #5: Handmade search and audience

Etsy attracts shoppers specifically searching for handmade, vintage, and creative products. Sellers benefit from stronger purchase intent and greater perceived value because Etsy's marketplace naturally filters for shoppers seeking one-of-a-kind goods. 

This setup works particularly well for artisans, vintage collectors, and creative entrepreneurs who want to connect with buyers who care deeply about craftsmanship and distinction.

Reason #6: Flexible shipping

Etsy lets sellers buy shipping labels from USPS, UPS, and other carriers. You control your own shipping policies, return windows, and how you handle each order. The platform also supports international shipping with automatic tax calculations and built-in customs forms.

Etsy reviews: What real users are saying 

Tapping the wisdom of crowds, I searched Trustpilot, Reddit, and YouTube to find recent user reviews about Etsy:

Etsy pros

• More unique items: A buyer said Etsy offers items they can’t find elsewhere and noted that its sellers feel more reliable than those on eBay. (July 2nd, 2026)

• Positive long-term experience: One user shared that Etsy has been an incredibly supportive and successful platform for their handcrafted spiritual tools. They said their shop, opened in 2021, has reached over 1,000 five-star sales. (July 20th, 2026)

• High profit potential: One user shared that her handcrafted spiritual tools earned over $100K in a year. She said the marketplace’s traffic, community, and buyer intent helped her grow quickly. (July 31st, 2026) 

Etsy cons

• Etsy withholds seller funds: One seller stated that Etsy held back part of their payout after suspending their account. (August 7th, 2026) 

• Purchases fell short of expectations: One buyer reported repeated disappointment with Etsy orders, saying items looked better online than in person, with poorer quality, inaccurate colors, and slow shipping. (November 28th, 2026)
  ‍
• Success takes years: A seller shared that it took over 1 full year to sell just 2 items, 2 years to sell 45 items, and she could finally call her shop a “business” after 3 years of hard work.

My personal take on selling on Etsy

I’ve sold vintage T-shirts on Etsy since 2017. Here’s what I’ve learned over the years by selling on Etsy:

Etsy’s highlights …

• Built-in SEO features: Etsy's search algorithm prioritizes handmade and vintage listings, helping your products appear in front of buyers actively searching for creative goods. You can optimize titles, tags, and descriptions to improve visibility. Read our SEO reseller guide for more tips.
  ‍
• Engaged, high-intent buyers: Etsy attracts over 86 million active buyers specifically searching for unique, handcrafted, and vintage items. In my experience, these shoppers value authenticity and one-of-a-kind products, like my Nirvana Nevermind tour tees. 
  ‍
• Low barrier to entry: Etsy charges just $0.20 per listing and requires no upfront inventory investment for digital products. Launch your shop in minutes without building a website, managing hosting, or learning complex e-commerce platforms.

Etsy’s hangups …

• High transaction and payment fees: Etsy charges a 6.5% transaction fee plus payment processing fees around 3% + $0.25 per sale. And once your shop exceeds $10,000 in revenue, Etsy takes an additional 12% for ad fees on sales attributed to off-site ads. 
  ‍
• Strict handmade and vintage requirements: The platform only allows handmade goods, vintage items (20+ years old), or craft supplies. You can't resell mass-produced retail products unless they meet these criteria. 
  ‍
• Shop management adds workload: Running an Etsy shop means handling your shop’s design, layout and appearance, and updating it when needed.

Top Etsy alternatives

Maybe you don’t craft your own handmade goods. Or you want another platform for selling your vintage Madonna tees. Try the following Etsy alternatives: 

Overall, Etsy is the go-to if you’re selling vintage goods or hand-crafted items. But if you’re just a fashion reseller and don’t offer much vintage, platforms like Depop, Poshmark, and eBay are a better fit. 

Sell electronics, niche collectibles, or retail home goods like kitchenware? Etsy’s a no-go. But here’s the good news: You can sell these items on platforms like Mercari and eBay, which allow for a wide range of products. 

My final verdict: Is Etsy right for you?

Etsy works best for sellers who focus on handmade, vintage, or craft-supply niches and commit to consistent shop management. After selling on Etsy for almost a decade, I’ve noticed that folks with the traits below tend to excel on the platform:

• Specialization in a craft, vintage, or supply sounds appealing: You’re either already a crafter, you love vintage goods like 90s band T-shirts, or you know how to source crafting material. Specialization is crucial for building brand expertise on Etsy.
• You’re keen to master the algorithm: You're willing to use tools like eRank and Etsy's search bar to find high-volume keywords. Competition, improving listings, and aiming to always “hit the spot” for buyer intent is what SEO is all about. 
• Customer service is your forte: Good Etsy sellers love building relationships with their buyers, as many become repeat customers. You’ll need to respond to messages within 24 hours, resolve issues quickly, and throw in a little appreciation like thank-you notes when buyers purchase items. 
• You want to diversify beyond one platform: You're open to crosslisting on eBay, Poshmark, Mercari, and Depop using tools like Nifty. Expanding to multiple marketplaces reduces Etsy dependence, tests products across audiences, and saves time when creating new listings.

Etsy gives you access to millions of buyers without managing complex infrastructure. The platform works when you treat it as one channel in a broader strategy rather than your only storefront. Overall, selling on Etsy pays off if you can stay flexible and maintain relationships with buyers.

Sell on Etsy and other platforms with Nifty

Now that you know that it’s worth it to sell on Etsy, the next step is deciding how to manage your shop while expanding your reach.

If you're ready to test Etsy or already selling there, Nifty lets you list and manage items across several platforms from one interface. You'll spend less time on busywork and more time creating products.

Here's why Nifty's so helpful:

• AI listing: Snap a pic and let Nifty's AI build a complete listing with SEO-optimized titles and descriptions, and trending hashtags. Plus, it's cloud-based, mobile-friendly, and easy to use.
• Crosslist now: With a couple of clicks, post your items across Poshmark, eBay, Mercari, Depop, and Etsy. (More marketplaces coming soon!) No copy-paste, no multi-tab juggling. It all happens in the background. 
• Automatic delisting? Handled: When you make a sale, Nifty's sales detection auto-delists that item from every marketplace. Say goodbye to double-selling disasters and “sorry, it's already gone” apology messages.
• Bulk tools = no busywork: Share and relist daily without lifting a finger. Update or discount dozens of items at once. You can even schedule drafts to go live while you sleep.
• Real analytics and profits: Track sales, fees, top performers, and slow movers in one clean dashboard, so you can actually see what's working and what needs to move.

See why over 10,000 sellers already use Nifty and start your 7-day free trial.

FAQs

1. How much does Etsy take in fees?

Etsy takes a $0.20 listing fee per item, a 6.5% transaction fee on each sale, and payment processing fees are around 3% + $0.25. If your shop exceeds $10,000 in annual revenue, Etsy also requires a 12% advertising fee on sales attributed to off-site ads.

2. Is Etsy better than Shopify for new sellers?

Yes, Etsy is better than Shopify for new sellers of handmade crafts, vintage goods, and craft supplies. Etsy requires minimal setup and offers built-in traffic, while Shopify demands more technical effort and independent marketing to drive customers. However, Shopify gives you full control over branding, fees, and customer data, but the platform is more complex than Etsy.

3. Can you actually make money selling on Etsy?

Yes, you can actually make money selling on Etsy if you specialize in handmade, vintage, or craft supplies and optimize your listings for search. Some sellers report earning over $100,000 annually, though success requires time, consistent effort, and smart product selection. Most new sellers take around 3 years to establish a steady income.